#BeautyReview: This $12 Eyeliner Is a Dream

May 18, 2017

I’ve said it before, and I’ll say it again, the Tom Ford Eye Defining Liquid ($56) is the greatest eyeliner, ever.  It suffers from two serious problems, however.  First, the obvious issue, the price.  I’m not averse to paying for a great product, particularly one that lasts for 3-months-plus, but this feels excessive.

The second?  You cannot travel with this eyeliner.  I don’t know whether it’s the pressurized cabin or the tumble and toil of the inside of a suitcase, but twice, my eyeliner exploded after a trip.  So when I went looking for a replacement, I decided that throwing away a $56 eyeliner was not an experience that I wanted to repeat.

I tried a few old standbys from Stila and Bobbi Brown.  I even switched back to pencil liner for a while.  But you cannot do a proper smoky eye without liquid liner, so I headed to Ulta to find a strong drugstore-priced performer.

The name, Physicians Formula Eye Booster 2-in-1 Lash Boosting Eyeliner + Serum ($12), doesn’t exactly roll off the tongue.  But what caught my eye was the box, which promised me, not only a great eyeliner, but also a serum that would help me grow fuller and thicker lashes.

First, let’s talk about the eyeliner.  The brush on this liner is phenomenal.  The tip is substantial, but flexes and bends to create both pencil thin lines and wider strokes.  (See examples, here.)  It also dispenses the perfect amount of product.  It’s one of the better brushes that I’ve seen on a liquid liner.

The liner comes in brown, black, and ultra black.  If you’re looking for black, just buy the ultra black, it’s the color you need.

As for the serum, I can’t tell you whether it works.  I’ve only been using it for a couple of weeks, and haven’t noticed a change.  Other users have noticed a change, however.  But frankly, I love the liner so much (and the price), if the serum doesn’t work, it isn’t a significant loss.

This is one of the best eyeliners that I have ever used.  It draws the perfect line nearly every time, no matter how rushed or careless I’m being.  From now on, I will spend a very respectable $12 on eyeliner, and I won’t even miss my Tom Ford.  Because a product that’s almost as good, at one-fifth the price, is definitely the way to go.

Style

share this post

Leave a Reply to HH Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. HH says:

    Belle – how well does it stand up to watery eyes? I’m talking seasonal allergy level watery, not “I was just fired” level of watery. I’m pretty sold on this eyeliner, but almost always use waterproof liner. Thanks!

  2. Whitley says:

    Bonus…you can get this for $7 on Amazon. Very excited to try this, I’ve been using Clinique’s $20 liner but excited to try this way more affordable option.

  3. Rachel says:

    I’ve tried to like this eyeliner so many times, but it just doesn’t have the staying power I need for my perpetually watery eyes and it’s not dark/inky enough. May I suggest you also try Wet n Wild’s Megaliner? It’s only $3, one bottle lasts 3+ months for me, and I swear that stuff is indestructible; it even stays on through my sweaty workouts. And bonus: it’s cruelty free!

  4. Anna says:

    On sale at Ulta- Buy 2 get 1 free!

  5. Molly says:

    Anything with eyelash serum makes me nervous because of Latisse’s reaction with blue eyes – does anyone know if this product’s “serum” has any kind of light-eyed color reaction?

    • Jenna says:

      I’ve been using this eyeliner for years and have not seen any changes in my blue eyes. I’ve never tried Latisse because I’m afraid of the potential discoloration.

      Of course, you’re probably not going to see Latisse-type results with this OTC serum. For me the results have been minimal if at all.

  6. SN says:

    Airplane pressurization is not at atmo, but slightly less, say 65% since the human body tolerates it. My guess the slightly lower pressures caused it to explode.

  7. SN says:

    Sorry i meant surface pressure.

  8. CS says:

    FYI – It’s $8 on Amazon. I just bought it!

  9. txattyjen says:

    Interesting on the explosion issue – I’ve used the Tom Ford one since it first came out and fly with it 4-6 times a month and never had that happen. Did you call Tom Ford and ask? They’ve always been good with me about replacing anything that broke (or that I dropped and shattered…).

  10. […] Sounds like I need to try this eyeliner. […]

Join The List

Stay up to date on the latest from Capitol Hill Style!

sUBSCRIBE

Ask Me Anything: March 2024

It’s almost the end of March, so let’s get to some of the reader questions that came in through Instagram last night. Time for Ask Me Anything.

2

READ MORE 

Recent Posts

The Find: A Cute Spring Dress

Need a cute dress for a spring event? Something simple and easy to wear, something you can dress up or down? This is the dress for you.

2

READ MORE 

Beauty Review: Bondi Boost

As I age, I notice many changes in my body. Most are fine. Some are frustrating. Like many women, I lost a lot of hair in my postpartum phase. Being anemic for more than a year after, it didn’t grow back in to its former glory. So I’ve tried any number of shampoos, pills and […]

2

READ MORE 

VIEW ALL POSTS

Ask the Edit, Style, Top Posts | March 28, 2024

Ask Me Anything: March 2024

It’s almost the end of March, so let’s get to some of the reader questions that came in through Instagram last night. Time for Ask Me Anything.

2

READ MORE 

Fantastic Finds, Posts, Style | March 28, 2024

The Find: A Cute Spring Dress

Need a cute dress for a spring event? Something simple and easy to wear, something you can dress up or down? This is the dress for you.

2

READ MORE 

Beauty, Posts | March 27, 2024

Beauty Review: Bondi Boost

As I age, I notice many changes in my body. Most are fine. Some are frustrating. Like many women, I lost a lot of hair in my postpartum phase. Being anemic for more than a year after, it didn’t grow back in to its former glory. So I’ve tried any number of shampoos, pills and […]

2

READ MORE 

Fantastic Finds, Posts, Style | March 27, 2024

The Find: Shirts That Don’t Gape

I remember when Rochelle Behrens launched The Shirt — a button-down blouse with anti-gape technology (a patented internal button that keeps the look smooth). The idea seemed brilliant, but at the time, my bust didn’t require an extra button. One baby later, I understand the need for some extra security.

6

READ MORE 

RECENT POSTS

©2023 CAPITOL HILL STYLE | SITE BY LEIGH THE STUDIO